Exploratory Factor Analysis with Promax Rotation and NMF — Identifying Latent Moral Dimensions
PCA (Principal Component Analysis) finds linear combinations that maximize total variance, treating all variance (shared + unique + error) as signal. It produces components, not factors. Components are uncorrelated by construction and represent mathematical decompositions, not latent constructs.
EFA (Exploratory Factor Analysis via Principal Axis Factoring) models only shared variance (communalities), explicitly separating common factors from unique/error variance. This is appropriate because:
Promax oblique rotation is used because moral dimensions are theoretically correlated and co-constitutive. An authority-focused commandment likely also involves loyalty; a purity commandment likely also involves self-restraint.
NMF (Non-negative Matrix Factorization) is provided as a complementary method because our data is non-negative (binary presence/absence), and NMF produces parts-based, additive representations that are naturally interpretable as "this commandment is composed of these moral ingredients."
Matrix dimensions: 85 commandments × 20 thematic coding variables
Coding variables:
self_restraintsocial_obligationritual_observanceepistemologicalphysical_actioncommunity_directedprohibitioninternal_statedivine_relationshipjustice_fairnesscompassion_carepurity_sanctityauthority_hierarchyloyalty_covenantself_cultivationnon_violencematerial_ethicsspeech_ethicssexual_ethicsenvironmentalTraditions: Islam, Judaism, Hinduism, Buddhism, Sikhism, Taoism, Zoroastrianism, Confucianism, Christianity
Values: Binary (0/1) with 0.5 for partial presence. Each commandment was coded for the presence/absence of each thematic dimension.
| Factor | Eigenvalue | % Variance | Cumulative % |
|---|---|---|---|
| Self-Mastery/Wisdom | 3.402 | 23.5% | 23.5% |
| Purity/Sanctity | 3.006 | 20.8% | 44.4% |
| Embodied Discipline | 1.968 | 13.6% | 58.0% |
| Fairness/Justice | 1.355 | 9.4% | 67.4% |
| Truth/Integrity | 1.144 | 7.9% | 75.3% |
| Non-Violence/Stewardship | 0.856 | 5.9% | 81.2% |
| Prohibition/Embodied Practice | 0.575 | 4.0% | 85.2% |
Loadings show how strongly each coding variable is associated with each latent factor. High absolute loadings (> 0.4) indicate that the variable is a strong indicator of the factor.
| Variable | Self-Mastery/Wisdom | Purity/Sanctity | Embodied Discipline | Fairness/Justice | Truth/Integrity | Non-Violence/Stewardship | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
self_restraint | -0.200 | 0.062 | 0.320 | -0.033 | 0.139 | -0.118 | 0.237 |
social_obligation | 0.585 | 0.549 | -0.120 | -0.133 | -0.046 | -0.120 | -0.086 |
ritual_observance | -0.008 | -0.547 | 0.157 | -0.063 | -0.104 | -0.057 | -0.236 |
epistemological | -0.688 | -0.010 | -0.422 | 0.023 | 0.026 | -0.032 | 0.021 |
physical_action | 0.210 | -0.174 | 0.178 | 0.084 | 0.146 | -0.052 | -0.438 |
community_directed | 0.281 | 0.042 | 0.049 | 0.169 | 0.002 | 0.121 | -0.327 |
prohibition | 0.253 | -0.074 | 0.273 | -0.017 | 0.077 | -0.157 | 0.765 |
internal_state | -0.699 | 0.014 | -0.147 | 0.138 | -0.219 | 0.073 | -0.078 |
divine_relationship | -0.027 | -0.696 | -0.124 | 0.018 | -0.043 | 0.035 | 0.015 |
justice_fairness | 0.340 | 0.266 | -0.175 | -0.327 | 0.219 | 0.110 | -0.039 |
compassion_care | 0.396 | 0.380 | -0.112 | 0.332 | -0.022 | -0.220 | -0.002 |
purity_sanctity | 0.069 | -0.111 | 0.750 | 0.042 | -0.096 | -0.031 | 0.093 |
authority_hierarchy | 0.294 | -0.591 | -0.127 | 0.030 | -0.044 | 0.126 | 0.178 |
loyalty_covenant | 0.382 | -0.128 | 0.099 | 0.056 | -0.100 | 0.424 | -0.035 |
self_cultivation | -0.853 | 0.073 | 0.127 | 0.051 | -0.102 | -0.023 | -0.165 |
non_violence | 0.090 | 0.123 | -0.074 | 0.193 | -0.141 | -0.679 | 0.185 |
material_ethics | 0.171 | 0.092 | -0.151 | 0.264 | 0.727 | 0.169 | 0.053 |
speech_ethics | 0.215 | 0.064 | -0.082 | -0.690 | -0.308 | 0.127 | 0.072 |
sexual_ethics | -0.050 | 0.270 | 0.677 | 0.064 | -0.084 | 0.333 | 0.156 |
environmental | 0.128 | -0.012 | 0.061 | 0.083 | -0.154 | -0.531 | -0.010 |
Since we used oblique rotation (Promax), factors are allowed to correlate. This table shows inter-factor correlations, confirming that moral dimensions are indeed related:
| Self-Mastery | Purity/Sanct | Embodied Dis | Fairness/Jus | Truth/Integr | Non-Violence | Prohibition/ | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Self-Mastery/Wisdom | 1.00 | -0.02 | -0.13 | 0.19 | -0.12 | 0.06 | -0.28 |
| Purity/Sanctity | -0.02 | 1.00 | -0.23 | -0.06 | 0.12 | -0.14 | 0.31 |
| Embodied Discipline | -0.13 | -0.23 | 1.00 | -0.16 | 0.29 | -0.27 | -0.06 |
| Fairness/Justice | 0.19 | -0.06 | -0.16 | 1.00 | -0.53 | 0.23 | -0.10 |
| Truth/Integrity | -0.12 | 0.12 | 0.29 | -0.53 | 1.00 | -0.36 | -0.15 |
| Non-Violence/Stewardship | 0.06 | -0.14 | -0.27 | 0.23 | -0.36 | 1.00 | 0.05 |
| Prohibition/Embodied Practice | -0.28 | 0.31 | -0.06 | -0.10 | -0.15 | 0.05 | 1.00 |
Each commandment is assigned to its primary factor (highest absolute loading). This shows which latent moral dimension best explains each commandment.
| ID | Tradition | Commandment | Primary Factor |
|---|---|---|---|
| ISL01 | Islam | Shahada — Declare there is no god but Allah | Purity/Sanctity |
| ISL02 | Islam | Salat — Perform five daily prayers | Purity/Sanctity |
| ISL03 | Islam | Zakat — Give 2.5% to those in need | Truth/Integrity |
| ISL04 | Islam | Sawm — Fast during Ramadan | Embodied Discipline |
| ISL05 | Islam | Hajj — Pilgrimage to Mecca | Purity/Sanctity |
| ISL06 | Islam | Do not kill except by right of justice | Non-Violence/Stewardship |
| ISL07 | Islam | Do not approach zina (unlawful intercourse) | Embodied Discipline |
| ISL08 | Islam | Give full measure and weigh with even balance | Truth/Integrity |
| ISL09 | Islam | Do not pursue that of which you have no knowledge | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| ISL10 | Islam | Be good to parents; do not say 'uff' to them | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| JUD01 | Judaism | I am the LORD your God — have no other gods | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| JUD02 | Judaism | Do not make graven images | Purity/Sanctity |
| JUD03 | Judaism | Remember the Sabbath and keep it holy | Purity/Sanctity |
| JUD04 | Judaism | Honor your father and mother | Fairness/Justice |
| JUD05 | Judaism | You shall not murder | Non-Violence/Stewardship |
| JUD06 | Judaism | You shall not steal | Truth/Integrity |
| JUD07 | Judaism | You shall not bear false witness | Fairness/Justice |
| JUD08 | Judaism | Establish courts of justice | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| JUD09 | Judaism | Love your neighbor as yourself | Fairness/Justice |
| JUD10 | Judaism | Do not eat flesh torn from a living animal | Non-Violence/Stewardship |
| HIN01 | Hinduism | Act without attachment to results (karma yoga) | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| HIN02 | Hinduism | Ahimsa — Non-violence to all living beings | Non-Violence/Stewardship |
| HIN03 | Hinduism | Satya — Truthfulness in thought, word, deed | Fairness/Justice |
| HIN04 | Hinduism | Brahmacharya — Right use of energy / continence | Embodied Discipline |
| HIN05 | Hinduism | Aparigraha — Non-possessiveness / non-greed | Truth/Integrity |
| HIN06 | Hinduism | Dedicate all actions to the Divine | Purity/Sanctity |
| HIN07 | Hinduism | Surrender completely to God | Truth/Integrity |
| HIN08 | Hinduism | Elevate yourself through self-discipline | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| HIN09 | Hinduism | Shaucha — Cleanliness/purity of body and mind | Embodied Discipline |
| HIN10 | Hinduism | Tapas — Austerity and discipline for growth | Embodied Discipline |
| BUD01 | Buddhism | Abstain from killing living beings | Non-Violence/Stewardship |
| BUD02 | Buddhism | Abstain from taking what is not given | Truth/Integrity |
| BUD03 | Buddhism | Abstain from sexual misconduct | Embodied Discipline |
| BUD04 | Buddhism | Abstain from false speech | Fairness/Justice |
| BUD05 | Buddhism | Abstain from intoxicants causing heedlessness | Embodied Discipline |
| BUD06 | Buddhism | Right View — understand the Four Noble Truths | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| BUD07 | Buddhism | Right Mindfulness — awareness of body, feelings, mind | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| BUD08 | Buddhism | Right Concentration — develop meditative absorption | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| BUD09 | Buddhism | Sentient beings are numberless; I vow to save them all | Fairness/Justice |
| BUD10 | Buddhism | Right Livelihood — earn without harming others | Truth/Integrity |
| SIK01 | Sikhism | Naam Japna — Meditate on God's Name | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| SIK02 | Sikhism | Kirat Karni — Earn an honest living | Truth/Integrity |
| SIK03 | Sikhism | Vand Chakna — Share with others | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| SIK04 | Sikhism | Treat all humans as equal regardless of caste | Purity/Sanctity |
| SIK05 | Sikhism | Overcome Kam (lust) — control desires | Embodied Discipline |
| SIK06 | Sikhism | Overcome Ahankar (ego/pride) | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| SIK07 | Sikhism | Serve the Sangat (community) through selfless seva | Fairness/Justice |
| SIK08 | Sikhism | Do not worship idols or created things | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| SIK09 | Sikhism | Do not consume intoxicants | Embodied Discipline |
| SIK10 | Sikhism | Maintain the five Ks (Panj Kakaar) | Purity/Sanctity |
| TAO01 | Taoism | Be like water — benefit all without competing | Truth/Integrity |
| TAO02 | Taoism | Practice Wu Wei — act without forcing | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| TAO03 | Taoism | Yield and overcome; bend and be straight | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| TAO04 | Taoism | Know when enough is enough | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| TAO05 | Taoism | The sage does not compete | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| TAO06 | Taoism | Compassion (Ci) — first of three treasures | Truth/Integrity |
| TAO07 | Taoism | Frugality (Jian) — second treasure | Truth/Integrity |
| TAO08 | Taoism | Humility — not daring to be first (third treasure) | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| TAO09 | Taoism | Empty yourself; maintain stillness | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| TAO10 | Taoism | Know yourself and be enlightened | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| ZOR01 | Zoroastrianism | Good Thoughts (Humata) | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| ZOR02 | Zoroastrianism | Good Words (Hukhta) | Fairness/Justice |
| ZOR03 | Zoroastrianism | Good Deeds (Hvarshta) | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| ZOR04 | Zoroastrianism | Choose Asha over Druj — choose truth over deceit | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| ZOR05 | Zoroastrianism | Cultivate the earth and make it flourish | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| ZOR06 | Zoroastrianism | Keep fire, water, and earth pure | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| ZOR07 | Zoroastrianism | Keep promises and contracts (Mithra) | Fairness/Justice |
| ZOR08 | Zoroastrianism | Oppose and resist evil actively | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| ZOR09 | Zoroastrianism | Practice charity to the poor and righteous | Truth/Integrity |
| ZOR10 | Zoroastrianism | Treat cattle and animals with kindness | Non-Violence/Stewardship |
| CON01 | Confucianism | Practice Ren (benevolence/humaneness) | Fairness/Justice |
| CON02 | Confucianism | Act with Yi (righteousness) at personal cost | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| CON03 | Confucianism | Observe Li (ritual propriety/proper conduct) | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| CON04 | Confucianism | Cultivate Zhi (wisdom through learning) | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| CON05 | Confucianism | Be trustworthy — keep your word (Xin) | Fairness/Justice |
| CON06 | Confucianism | Xiao — serve parents with filial piety | Fairness/Justice |
| CON07 | Confucianism | Do not do to others what you do not want done to you | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| CON08 | Confucianism | When you see a worthy person, think how to equal them | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| CON09 | Confucianism | Examine yourself daily | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| CON10 | Confucianism | Study and practice constantly | Self-Mastery/Wisdom |
| CHR01 | Christianity | Love God with all heart, soul, mind, strength | Truth/Integrity |
| CHR02 | Christianity | Love your neighbor as yourself | Fairness/Justice |
| CHR03 | Christianity | Turn the other cheek; do not resist evil with evil | Prohibition/Embodied Practice |
| CHR04 | Christianity | Give to the one who asks; it is more blessed to give | Truth/Integrity |
| CHR05 | Christianity | Do not commit adultery; lust in heart is adultery | Embodied Discipline |
Each tradition's "moral profile" shows relative emphasis across the seven latent factors. Normalized to [0,1] within each tradition to show the shape of emphasis rather than absolute volume.
| Tradition | Self-Mastery | Purity/Sanct | Embodied Dis | Fairness/Jus | Truth/Integr | Non-Violence | Prohibition/ |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Islam | 0.61 | 0.00 | 1.00 | 0.38 | 0.41 | 0.42 | 0.26 |
| Judaism | 1.00 | 0.00 | 0.71 | 0.42 | 0.33 | 0.06 | 0.64 |
| Hinduism | 0.00 | 0.42 | 1.00 | 0.54 | 0.66 | 0.33 | 0.42 |
| Buddhism | 0.30 | 0.90 | 1.00 | 0.34 | 0.92 | 0.00 | 0.72 |
| Sikhism | 0.55 | 0.20 | 0.98 | 1.00 | 0.76 | 0.53 | 0.00 |
| Taoism | 0.00 | 1.00 | 0.57 | 1.00 | 0.63 | 0.45 | 0.79 |
| Zoroastrianism | 1.00 | 0.91 | 0.74 | 0.39 | 0.88 | 0.33 | 0.00 |
| Confucianism | 0.07 | 1.00 | 0.27 | 0.64 | 0.10 | 0.53 | 0.00 |
| Christianity | 0.54 | 0.57 | 0.41 | 1.00 | 0.00 | 0.63 | 0.62 |
Jonathan Haidt's Moral Foundations Theory (MFT) identifies six innate moral foundations. Here we compare our empirically extracted factors with Haidt's theoretical framework:
| Haidt Foundation | Description | Mapped Factor | Strength |
|---|---|---|---|
| Care/Harm | Evolved from mammalian attachment systems. Sensitivity to suffering. | Non-Violence/Stewardship | 0.90 |
| Fairness/Cheating | Evolved from reciprocal altruism. Sensitivity to proportionality and reciprocity. | Fairness/Justice | 1.28 |
| Loyalty/Betrayal | Evolved from tribal coalitional psychology. In-group solidarity. | Self-Mastery/Wisdom | 0.66 |
| Authority/Subversion | Evolved from primate social hierarchies. Respect for legitimate authority. | Purity/Sanctity | 0.59 |
| Sanctity/Degradation | Evolved from pathogen-avoidance systems. Purity and contamination. | Embodied Discipline | 1.58 |
| Liberty/Oppression | Sensitivity to domination and tyranny. Desire for autonomy. | Self-Mastery/Wisdom | 1.54 |
Haidt's MFT was designed to explain intuitive moral judgments in modern secular populations. Our factor analysis of religious commandments reveals two additional dimensions — Self-Mastery and Transcendence — that are essential to understanding pre-modern religious ethics but are invisible to Haidt's framework, which was built on surveys of American undergraduates and internet users.
Non-negative Matrix Factorization provides a parts-based decomposition where each commandment is expressed as an additive combination of basis moral components. This is particularly suitable for binary data and produces directly interpretable "moral ingredients."
Reconstruction error: 9.6220
NMF factors tend to be sparser than EFA factors (fewer variables load heavily on each), making them useful as a "checklist" decomposition: each commandment is literally composed of specific moral elements.
Western/Abrahamic traditions (Islam, Judaism, Christianity) exhibit a factor structure dominated by:
Eastern traditions (Buddhism, Hinduism, Taoism, Confucianism) exhibit:
Sikhism and Zoroastrianism occupy intermediate positions — Sikhism combines Abrahamic monotheistic authority with Indian self-cultivation traditions; Zoroastrianism combines active ethical dualism (Western-like) with personal moral choice (Eastern-like).
{
"methodology": {
"primary_method": "Exploratory Factor Analysis (EFA) via Principal Axis Factoring",
"rotation": "Promax (oblique, power=3)",
"alternative_method": "Non-negative Matrix Factorization (NMF)",
"n_commandments": 85,
"n_coding_variables": 20,
"n_factors_extracted": 7,
"coding_variables": [
"self_restraint",
"social_obligation",
"ritual_observance",
"epistemological",
"physical_action",
"community_directed",
"prohibition",
"internal_state",
"divine_relationship",
"justice_fairness",
"compassion_care",
"purity_sanctity",
"authority_hierarchy",
"loyalty_covenant",
"self_cultivation",
"non_violence",
"material_ethics",
"speech_ethics",
"sexual_ethics",
"environmental"
]
},
"eigenvalues": [
3.402038990419944,
3.0059069233946887,
1.9681271128905422,
1.3551077464280652,
1.14441645619728,
0.8562264099516176,
0.57485992380736,
0.32726459236996874,
0.28109001276935,
0.21372673017723,
0.1532548986745583,
0.07544254268996789,
0.019728119085664714,
-0.043895393898405057,
-0.0705895280809506,
-0.112252394526763,
-0.16478762614169043,
-0.18137709578817696,
-0.2012751340159493,
-0.29638483911645747
],
"variance_explained": [
0.23547184916021446,
0.20805360069311482,
0.1362237563883663,
0.09379367131337887,
0.07921069097355908,
0.059263640604610424,
0.03978888238735616
],
"cumulative_variance": [
0.23547184916021446,
0.4435254498533293,
0.5797492062416956,
0.6735428775550745,
0.7527535685286335,
0.8120172091332439,
0.8518060915206
],
"communalities": {
"self_restraint": 0.44922590419644826,
"social_obligation": 0.8649561645055184,
"ritual_observance": 0.6546041353561719,
"epistemological": 0.6730889021917097,
"physical_action": 0.6141753175780438,
"community_directed": 0.3865394149456296,
"prohibition": 0.7817792691560861,
"internal_state": 0.6471220067993212,
"divine_relationship": 0.6267579573496604,
"justice_fairness": 0.5431976432623313,
"compassion_care": 0.667373447541117,
"purity_sanctity": 0.7255191192489979,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.5824119746653628,
"loyalty_covenant": 0.5545149815542468,
"self_cultivation": 0.7853268619896361,
"non_violence": 0.6115185140142757,
"material_ethics": 0.6404855562301262,
"speech_ethics": 0.5686291874137147,
"sexual_ethics": 0.5856256534147465,
"environmental": 0.34383155167636337
},
"factor_labels": [
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom",
"Purity/Sanctity",
"Embodied Discipline",
"Fairness/Justice",
"Truth/Integrity",
"Non-Violence/Stewardship",
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
],
"factor_correlations": [
[
0.9999999999999998,
-0.017585133234897493,
-0.13154117455480321,
0.18946683449724838,
-0.12131077175931441,
0.06046074347170724,
-0.2774445305278242
],
[
-0.017585133234897493,
1.0,
-0.22933685887788346,
-0.05596935725791291,
0.1191163773497155,
-0.1397514854836281,
0.3066796371615777
],
[
-0.13154117455480321,
-0.22933685887788346,
1.0000000000000002,
-0.16234026031917,
0.28532369515028355,
-0.26897959633099866,
-0.05715031225531343
],
[
0.18946683449724838,
-0.05596935725791291,
-0.16234026031917,
1.0,
-0.5332940993662448,
0.22528819761235394,
-0.09632285762585764
],
[
-0.12131077175931441,
0.1191163773497155,
0.28532369515028355,
-0.5332940993662448,
1.0000000000000002,
-0.3572433140049182,
-0.1456977127275327
],
[
0.06046074347170724,
-0.1397514854836281,
-0.26897959633099866,
0.22528819761235394,
-0.3572433140049182,
1.0000000000000002,
0.05409053439173345
],
[
-0.2774445305278242,
0.3066796371615777,
-0.05715031225531343,
-0.09632285762585764,
-0.1456977127275327,
0.05409053439173345,
1.0
]
],
"loadings_matrix": {
"self_restraint": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.19969533076788112,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.06197469377848257,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.3199198680371195,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.03259550494349202,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.13897711510734906,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.11781856318601092,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.23655079181817276
},
"social_obligation": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5848761164436538,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5489276452120538,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.12034212736618764,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.1333922701165756,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.04580240177438853,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.11983806276387445,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.0859242725245433
},
"ritual_observance": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.00767618562209365,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.5474694102330225,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.1570758237394748,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.06278126142751904,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.10418996765069463,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.057430474101370574,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.23600378306697967
},
"epistemological": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.6879481255842617,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.009562430673118292,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.4215764053157296,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.02278837203831492,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.025878432877446695,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.03227317474045978,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.020868868540805864
},
"physical_action": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.20999166063022576,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.1738090277949489,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.17821118996457738,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.0843070428046655,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.14552968571499128,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.05240156244667172,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.4381349310006932
},
"community_directed": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.28092854564825886,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.041962538523195016,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.048952713832261754,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.16895754851517716,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.0019984672958811996,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.12136953378101706,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.3274858605833957
},
"prohibition": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.25271491233612786,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.07353397088347059,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.2731714171318123,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.016695350805346537,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.07694035670178992,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.15718029366206157,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7649854342323341
},
"internal_state": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.699428006491032,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.01368520001731595,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.14708608579093807,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.13756257060171515,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.21938970369640695,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.07305698740793723,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.07775244945716468
},
"divine_relationship": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.027141111588028486,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.6958221324129472,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.12376497903752127,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.01802988713535558,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.04319001802759697,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.03536691458422085,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.014504310880978715
},
"justice_fairness": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.3398913498505952,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.26576532856922697,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.17514382221935962,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.32661976534209247,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.21908895976962428,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.11043984621085073,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.03856294794688564
},
"compassion_care": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.3963544396696425,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.3799018018511356,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.11183335824393752,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.3319007973869017,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.022466078092006157,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.21954565601031711,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.0015512405761164022
},
"purity_sanctity": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.06947278790023503,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.11082412970962711,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.7501202205779453,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.04180356039904074,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.09604028307690174,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.030824894402894074,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.09322487585196391
},
"authority_hierarchy": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.29418832120660854,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.5913699145494932,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.12655499391161576,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.02980841073328339,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.04406562765541025,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.1258704259848268,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.1784558394817357
},
"loyalty_covenant": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.381970495631817,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.12845300447184518,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.09939984074864293,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.05606719549158155,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.09966028939132844,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.4241746187021629,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.034575673916100585
},
"self_cultivation": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8528177736122112,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.07287288704025505,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.12655617788986248,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.05084628735493445,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.10187128913408365,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.022683802055221802,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.1650933756344149
},
"non_violence": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.09006183289147834,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.12348426894978982,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.07382526356620452,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.19256623016413477,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.14058906442706262,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.679304686395243,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.18536786511241157
},
"material_ethics": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.17100772299913644,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.09184865163063978,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.15146974274607514,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.264233141602662,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.7267807768567293,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.1692596614073615,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.053192793835305674
},
"speech_ethics": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.2145605279317165,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.06398330883031429,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.082002434539756,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.6896663763804157,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.30835324567902617,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.12699137894247464,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.07155859661023665
},
"sexual_ethics": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.05009841651499174,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.2697731667706827,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.6765138936966175,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.06375502352914497,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.08447252391906067,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.3334993381052727,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.15583008808413276
},
"environmental": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.1276745779136359,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.011720878649167248,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.06094390640906431,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.08326577083267236,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.15360851033492154,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.5314951871533029,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.009944080037532005
}
},
"commandment_factor_scores": [
{
"id": "ISL01",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Shahada \u2014 Declare there is no god but Allah",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.3116149360905177,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.069623982160292,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.12834919588382154,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.12916242138033918,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.7592933629879635,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.4349045589731417,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.34248243054276184
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "ISL02",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Salat \u2014 Perform five daily prayers",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.3699235388087455,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.0592304946855766,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.8700548926894158,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.11811257282669431,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.2164131408938557,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.43278020727742045,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.5587933604279501
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "ISL03",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Zakat \u2014 Give 2.5% to those in need",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6815885768302211,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.46523303271755273,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.18229656658165763,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.31776714514301097,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.9052742704148317,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.13388582339155272,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.6981404248783831
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "ISL04",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Sawm \u2014 Fast during Ramadan",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.19630379246230423,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.7229189679770018,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0132981825593268,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.2977306117486791,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.11214441112814694,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.0003027507380480299,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.9834141833730161
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "ISL05",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Hajj \u2014 Pilgrimage to Mecca",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6028127739615067,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.212943964692444,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.5735941966267787,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.49698496694195793,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.31469004732097144,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.24187645934406984,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.752823648182302
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "ISL06",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Do not kill except by right of justice",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.39253148855961834,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4862926831728538,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.5115596987561283,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.14117359290791406,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.2444375151272458,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.9182111185888324,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.6436193045769592
},
"primary_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship"
},
{
"id": "ISL07",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Do not approach zina (unlawful intercourse)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.2314666003462794,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.14800410725430102,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.2424582423573929,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.19939211156607567,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.09769831970444662,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.3973194463822369,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7333884596496205
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "ISL08",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Give full measure and weigh with even balance",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.49486242562075944,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.2138395559653711,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.04930064793794348,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.2361476248707706,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.9848474219586285,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.18696217533341233,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.5843291785227358
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "ISL09",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Do not pursue that of which you have no knowledge",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.7875414130707726,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.154535137818361,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.029602666507835947,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.6980848755944422,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.0502722028879275,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.09516611250532486,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7789734564308708
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "ISL10",
"tradition": "Islam",
"text": "Be good to parents; do not say 'uff' to them",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6867964544099107,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.11958226597653861,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.18597542448903304,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.059222070126285664,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.761018927195801,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.37624040011401955,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 1.028663174723998
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "JUD01",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "I am the LORD your God \u2014 have no other gods",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.24194847586013768,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.710064809373867,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.43912144483880844,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8760509324742088,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.9002840142255957,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.8032187569853484,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 1.0569421688601754
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "JUD02",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "Do not make graven images",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.2568956089960878,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.157272738346322,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.4387122568421811,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.0044657643870969765,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.050830501231574454,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.18661198597017317,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.5741661061421941
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "JUD03",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "Remember the Sabbath and keep it holy",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.46552108569794304,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.2054792982315141,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.8331392023733147,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.26233713723091145,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.038446282434907164,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.04028781143795801,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.6531941277725647
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "JUD04",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "Honor your father and mother",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.7957303701019539,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.0069510848102784795,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.23130964879143384,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8737300913597758,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.6807431954877254,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.3845968086815936,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.23763406819759025
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "JUD05",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "You shall not murder",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.39253148855961834,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4862926831728538,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.5115596987561283,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.14117359290791406,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.2444375151272458,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.9182111185888324,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.6436193045769592
},
"primary_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship"
},
{
"id": "JUD06",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "You shall not steal",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.1492924785806975,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.3115290830935021,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.1999010703664162,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.7018730681852705,
"Truth/Integrity": 1.4741186945143991,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.31630524705158575,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.5745903597585003
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "JUD07",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "You shall not bear false witness",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.1985624695610841,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.3493753962413266,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.19116591747699244,
"Fairness/Justice": -1.4831605645325365,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.48947011681913566,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.3479358008424612,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.5679049785326195
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "JUD08",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "Establish courts of justice",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6035503428193622,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.04887645569300786,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.013308070425154611,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.21250342824403637,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.2546326120468726,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.03767364560313577,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.7297569263260044
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "JUD09",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "Love your neighbor as yourself",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5188025695375175,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5833652595110498,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.41668431076643897,
"Fairness/Justice": 1.3466917797629832,
"Truth/Integrity": -1.3135874012205238,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.7714029411277497,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.17627364521868388
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "JUD10",
"tradition": "Judaism",
"text": "Do not eat flesh torn from a living animal",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.078124914253153,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.2903034390598412,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0896985426422,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.24367341089032754,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.563523141142535,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -1.5242930368421428,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.16919118950678758
},
"primary_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship"
},
{
"id": "HIN01",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Act without attachment to results (karma yoga)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.7821726478336486,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.336267909737886,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.14022227064440101,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.07671349209005354,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.349867324122689,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.28592580019931063,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.3399812026327505
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "HIN02",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Ahimsa \u2014 Non-violence to all living beings",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.1101804280947594,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.559452066511844,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.12856275309650508,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.5936033695075512,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.5578738421159767,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -1.084093530415271,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.587134403763817
},
"primary_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship"
},
{
"id": "HIN03",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Satya \u2014 Truthfulness in thought, word, deed",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.5916076783330317,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5988031469161046,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.13827281802333768,
"Fairness/Justice": -1.2512328859991786,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.11836667466325076,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.14393373382091365,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.04750361688232588
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "HIN04",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Brahmacharya \u2014 Right use of energy / continence",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.605409271136969,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.17663218628684374,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.3357675343368098,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.021711086760582143,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.17669847075793266,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.06389914747315473,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.42464389880737957
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "HIN05",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Aparigraha \u2014 Non-possessiveness / non-greed",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8368114040511592,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.11668882467053651,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.0383378193972597,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.08320262075282368,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.9343763748073359,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.06353555871444944,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7856588376567517
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "HIN06",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Dedicate all actions to the Divine",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.04060588400808113,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.0226161380311485,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.05540534036353206,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.5093706738413997,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.5500358368169452,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.35663256560997386,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.5244167637059952
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "HIN07",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Surrender completely to God",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.19310833422327606,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.6422071363453,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.5076171487012076,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8747874448593063,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.9747941801518927,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.8587793481961876,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.42354776145036616
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "HIN08",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Elevate yourself through self-discipline",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8786216945208178,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18903474410714094,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.0013980258913947885,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.0014566635627860508,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.05654305352629061,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.05314717209540337,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.11761533240460109
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "HIN09",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Shaucha \u2014 Cleanliness/purity of body and mind",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.3686359814971865,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.43543977104193454,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.30990085472772,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.643790895958432,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.8029857391224173,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.8101901924571018,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.9029271338544242
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "HIN10",
"tradition": "Hinduism",
"text": "Tapas \u2014 Austerity and discipline for growth",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.5620651279947042,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.35341965674550635,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.1587231900632666,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.35433129091224186,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.4370743085380267,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.610348834758367,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.8428414983921413
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "BUD01",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Abstain from killing living beings",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.08324871840275833,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.47743195221541584,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.27974041776095854,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.30414376446136104,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.19196241153158608,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -1.2839348881140058,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.527048768301534
},
"primary_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship"
},
{
"id": "BUD02",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Abstain from taking what is not given",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.1492924785806975,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.3115290830935021,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.1999010703664162,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.7018730681852705,
"Truth/Integrity": 1.4741186945143991,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.31630524705158575,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.5745903597585003
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "BUD03",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Abstain from sexual misconduct",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.07793617343147566,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.36188735671205596,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0927835318998513,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.17079795247227647,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.13584625097525455,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.07763964962376302,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7056125862330274
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "BUD04",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Abstain from false speech",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.1985624695610841,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.3493753962413266,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.19116591747699244,
"Fairness/Justice": -1.4831605645325365,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.48947011681913566,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.3479358008424612,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.5679049785326195
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "BUD05",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Abstain from intoxicants causing heedlessness",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.5267689395333759,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.10016853821340463,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0556674034884774,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.163777657213465,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.4413550400096152,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.4637441656937015,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.07923721914167486
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "BUD06",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Right View \u2014 understand the Four Noble Truths",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.7413300062572543,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18157007764621108,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.26094303163793103,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.23319116614826035,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.2965932762295879,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.14844147581070843,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.017985811994864043
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "BUD07",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Right Mindfulness \u2014 awareness of body, feelings, mind",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8786216945208178,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18903474410714094,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.0013980258913947885,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.0014566635627860508,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.05654305352629061,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.05314717209540337,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.11761533240460109
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "BUD08",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Right Concentration \u2014 develop meditative absorption",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.5475717840881162,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.48374248735394865,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.6195942414930372,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.28984939969179047,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.39534697527976664,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.5026577969713149,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.7643928375602264
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "BUD09",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Sentient beings are numberless; I vow to save them all",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5188025695375175,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5833652595110498,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.41668431076643897,
"Fairness/Justice": 1.3466917797629832,
"Truth/Integrity": -1.3135874012205238,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.7714029411277497,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.17627364521868388
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "BUD10",
"tradition": "Buddhism",
"text": "Right Livelihood \u2014 earn without harming others",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.39701407963634444,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4724914246162891,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.17218225024690628,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.13208300910184312,
"Truth/Integrity": 1.2747562435738418,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.9462747405698835,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.40584347436829094
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "SIK01",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Naam Japna \u2014 Meditate on God's Name",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.19902093538539542,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.7024418329419947,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.24048246042981242,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.3146631477377971,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.36264720362611175,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.18153648977357922,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.7607518382219565
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "SIK02",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Kirat Karni \u2014 Earn an honest living",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.16317484582236075,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.23972063512795883,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.3766168403473832,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.8199045763093856,
"Truth/Integrity": 1.726205333637838,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.49599583558920585,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.5641136461368907
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "SIK03",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Vand Chakna \u2014 Share with others",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.8188802650937848,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4577683662566229,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.07724843916487856,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.5524149748540573,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.552137940658953,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.33547447129766456,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.7977699452881202
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "SIK04",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Treat all humans as equal regardless of caste",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.13744238987578872,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.7215433131377091,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.6331314241937127,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.5292278475080743,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.5140858178822915,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.25735590181078283,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.23456700412713452
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "SIK05",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Overcome Kam (lust) \u2014 control desires",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.6192916383786322,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.24844063425238705,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.159051764355843,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.1397425948846972,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.07538816836550635,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.11579144106446532,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7140601070880115
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "SIK06",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Overcome Ahankar (ego/pride)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8297815528839563,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.12117707107857405,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.06709767797100435,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.00019317594788346992,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.13105321945258755,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.10870776330624252,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7510097398144105
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "SIK07",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Serve the Sangat (community) through selfless seva",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.77495422491356,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.36167902422051135,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.020295172258619376,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.9404641542075807,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.6210791655863971,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.33631040368055565,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.7416688791665483
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "SIK08",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Do not worship idols or created things",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.0030615513484990864,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.7544844584877848,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.47619748526911426,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.24057237122734026,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.10476495119357453,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.13533849694433114,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 1.0293133384533548
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "SIK09",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Do not consume intoxicants",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.3333397930358581,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.18218865250983282,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.2068450681529308,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.4532372622596551,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.8072664705940058,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.6635855233924364,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.019151583679391904
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
},
{
"id": "SIK10",
"tradition": "Sikhism",
"text": "Maintain the five Ks (Panj Kakaar)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6004428489637724,
"Purity/Sanctity": -1.150448528875428,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.08626083671033447,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.5407112621714368,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.3397811133525628,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.348331221308846,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.698231519074502
},
"primary_factor": "Purity/Sanctity"
},
{
"id": "TAO01",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Be like water \u2014 benefit all without competing",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.3136727874160957,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.6901736147595691,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.5365639940746678,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8405731866201994,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.8747872737067108,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.36015750472171276,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.07392348182398939
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "TAO02",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Practice Wu Wei \u2014 act without forcing",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8448951567121734,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.1966017887437758,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.10498920319896504,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.040054528419158936,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.02327051907295303,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.0506746204508515,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.16532839585283104
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "TAO03",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Yield and overcome; bend and be straight",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.6938697057273755,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.20496569116436883,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.31289117816905176,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.39389172258238236,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.44305748828341374,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.3235400542988645,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.12199701407585134
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "TAO04",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Know when enough is enough",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8856515456880207,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18454649769910342,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.030157884465139444,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.0819391331379211,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.859866208881039,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.007974967503610285,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.1522644302469422
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "TAO05",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "The sage does not compete",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.6373434089637642,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4882631052503263,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.12453254475877548,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.07880434613573249,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.2166660659406618,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.58344877775672,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.11929403254611404
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "TAO06",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Compassion (Ci) \u2014 first of three treasures",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.23422807234364074,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5906236514097861,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.42679862710119026,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8968416255181292,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.9441054280615135,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.30875762283368646,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.11602330529140831
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "TAO07",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Frugality (Jian) \u2014 second treasure",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.4543022197161817,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.08334233092182283,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.3770446719569768,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.21061063743515915,
"Truth/Integrity": 1.1843915889411303,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.22114678587656886,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.019691998294694965
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "TAO08",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Humility \u2014 not daring to be first (third treasure)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.4468835300193217,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.44568343925131615,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.183440493530008,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.08498637582527961,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.11158790441113553,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.12479770832137085,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.09658796261422747
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "TAO09",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Empty yourself; maintain stillness",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8313512035366402,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.5177105803044444,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.0665622872382233,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.1492356176647153,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.09349995352766138,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.252839880726356,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.12335591427117558
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "TAO10",
"tradition": "Taoism",
"text": "Know yourself and be enlightened",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.7413300062572543,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18157007764621108,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.26094303163793103,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.23319116614826035,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.2965932762295879,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.14844147581070843,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.017985811994864043
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "ZOR01",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Good Thoughts (Humata)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.6903741149098267,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.2821476660903602,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.2891364399704455,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.23825380990597006,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.07330067466101384,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.10243333883602418,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.07276435196904885
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "ZOR02",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Good Words (Hukhta)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.2870140161877861,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.40976840280896365,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.13687479213194287,
"Fairness/Justice": -1.2497762224363926,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.06182362113696016,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.0907865617255103,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.165118949286927
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "ZOR03",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Good Deeds (Hvarshta)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.49387531853723204,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.44611939104523907,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.006654750394764514,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.14153153252562578,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.2647609705170407,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.3178767671459916,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.6441332947013564
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "ZOR04",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Choose Asha over Druj \u2014 choose truth over deceit",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.6566475771011823,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.1034888667605566,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.3927276172780158,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.1967426179240251,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.04002814020767629,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.10490589048057603,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.025051288520818893
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "ZOR05",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Cultivate the earth and make it flourish",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.4482031265683373,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.11957577175276102,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.2810236037782151,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.05373871221697718,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.002780280779962341,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.6202179103672296,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.9832840496784175
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "ZOR06",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Keep fire, water, and earth pure",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.30402555752307436,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.9254977361008682,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.9075036491605375,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.05732699037882753,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.191573154226051,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.8680453054112147,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -1.1765149235225199
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "ZOR07",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Keep promises and contracts (Mithra)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.48140990772262104,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.39135199010730576,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.20464597879484636,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.900667100708824,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.3263979607863708,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.39058280129099604,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.085704961263035
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "ZOR08",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Oppose and resist evil actively",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.14779377656425396,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.0668722034794221,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.10893714879743209,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.33768174627091124,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.17056188348948287,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.13726548293160046,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.590593565478456
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "ZOR09",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Practice charity to the poor and righteous",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6244843735589497,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4761847789582808,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.009477252501975057,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.20330585312648877,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.9403595225822841,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.14589489171884185,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.8771839333120122
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "ZOR10",
"tradition": "Zoroastrianism",
"text": "Treat cattle and animals with kindness",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5444034541934004,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.3177929269200121,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.05065165721120413,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.4801186904731123,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.3209442059945288,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -1.1973064861832639,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.557314141456821
},
"primary_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship"
},
{
"id": "CON01",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Practice Ren (benevolence/humaneness)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.01442599771726727,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.6821475830816381,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.20265359931935029,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.9382240536105947,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.8974337154666896,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.22530323554899312,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.409658249789349
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "CON02",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Act with Yi (righteousness) at personal cost",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.00248429503228792,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.317110125943997,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.2920912179587768,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.7280111477238662,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.5976779523577143,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.4043097348371372,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.852362880935742
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "CON03",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Observe Li (ritual propriety/proper conduct)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.4288467163839042,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.46309816923689573,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.44598183409108444,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.1649964279847266,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.3081044253668578,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.39541941681006776,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.8280615520763611
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "CON04",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Cultivate Zhi (wisdom through learning)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.7413300062572543,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18157007764621108,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.26094303163793103,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.23319116614826035,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.2965932762295879,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.14844147581070843,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.017985811994864043
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "CON05",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Be trustworthy \u2014 keep your word (Xin)",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.48140990772262104,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.39135199010730576,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.20464597879484636,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.900667100708824,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.3263979607863708,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.39058280129099604,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.085704961263035
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "CON06",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Xiao \u2014 serve parents with filial piety",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.7957303701019539,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.0069510848102784795,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.23130964879143384,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8737300913597758,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.6807431954877254,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.3845968086815936,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.23763406819759025
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "CON07",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Do not do to others what you do not want done to you",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.08864806293983385,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.6265966722489928,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.3310280710513115,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.034401916460523096,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.041285281089389114,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.1266030081415249,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7661566601454088
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "CON08",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "When you see a worthy person, think how to equal them",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.5829149548799399,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.13860422744294254,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.44602015170421144,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.42789869225186294,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.48398190942042135,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.323537551647103,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.2543208865108253
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "CON09",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Examine yourself daily",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.8786216945208178,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18903474410714094,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.0013980258913947885,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.0014566635627860508,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.05654305352629061,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.05314717209540337,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.11761533240460109
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "CON10",
"tradition": "Confucianism",
"text": "Study and practice constantly",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.815899185642293,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.049368623113030766,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.2438134479519713,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.11822468407199853,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.38313985857602656,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.28839835184386253,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.38769426608098045
},
"primary_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom"
},
{
"id": "CHR01",
"tradition": "Christianity",
"text": "Love God with all heart, soul, mind, strength",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.19310833422327606,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.6422071363453,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.5076171487012076,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.8747874448593063,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.9747941801518927,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.8587793481961876,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.42354776145036616
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "CHR02",
"tradition": "Christianity",
"text": "Love your neighbor as yourself",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5188025695375175,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5833652595110498,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.41668431076643897,
"Fairness/Justice": 1.3466917797629832,
"Truth/Integrity": -1.3135874012205238,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.7714029411277497,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.17627364521868388
},
"primary_factor": "Fairness/Justice"
},
{
"id": "CHR03",
"tradition": "Christianity",
"text": "Turn the other cheek; do not resist evil with evil",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.14577652571693875,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.5302306448421491,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.09875791749225496,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.6634572834219854,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.516458932379338,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.5659068619506373,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.8490472331109549
},
"primary_factor": "Prohibition/Embodied Practice"
},
{
"id": "CHR04",
"tradition": "Christianity",
"text": "Give to the one who asks; it is more blessed to give",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.4358895760226016,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.34105355619305244,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.00722120063599465,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.4133092402293118,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.6981901749811873,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.22669642557951428,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.5187340328951024
},
"primary_factor": "Truth/Integrity"
},
{
"id": "CHR05",
"tradition": "Christianity",
"text": "Do not commit adultery; lust in heart is adultery",
"scores": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.42489574684379716,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.23002422155072919,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0912805776929395,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.4888517166122658,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.4636097502888373,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.5971608040809717,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7934740951119035
},
"primary_factor": "Embodied Discipline"
}
],
"tradition_profiles": {
"Islam": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.15849713107844324,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.2477230626610337,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.4157840473643626,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.004841581794584904,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.025585507716930467,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.03253341759049033,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.07353388305457007
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.6122318624798587,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.0,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.3806509992725646,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.4119150590074356,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.42238655172933565,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.26252797743161543
}
},
"Judaism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.3700959803967555,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.16744832338755417,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.21637532136353968,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.05808916404548912,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.01191832499196761,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.13315245166656814,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.17895553398623928
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 1.0,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.0,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.7140316473432552,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.41957004445077417,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.33367788871871823,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.06380101412952054,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.6444191761220641
}
},
"Hinduism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.45830017832470815,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.11493396434093058,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.35196317700135543,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.024485003280102908,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.07932080864531284,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.18996620561278102,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.11683577789994808
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.0,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.4237711254331639,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.5354002154892352,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.6635138852523736,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.3311688365864023,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.421423970589598
}
},
"Buddhism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.1269435935249687,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.2342774268575638,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.29320094644368744,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.10589716043873638,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.2465293285716606,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.3071795044023661,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.12434850992196197
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.30020283076074467,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.9018563654044883,
"Embodied Discipline": 1.0,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.33525799129532535,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.9222632618929258,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.0,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7187576039763132
}
},
"Sikhism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.05165222063339238,
"Purity/Sanctity": -0.0639234428741277,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.1929482127080983,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.19844613380740594,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.11989165443369403,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.044184930359234,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.12835680629799837
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5508182603049169,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.19716274095664152,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.9831766473779752,
"Fairness/Justice": 1.0,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.7596273786631919,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.5279687404329416,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.0
}
},
"Taoism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.5615071491693187,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.2154856039054284,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.11698290106805127,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.21204630776366296,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.07257691662102397,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.2084896446679033,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.05271805966519024
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.0,
"Purity/Sanctity": 1.0,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.5721086153534614,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.9955735801548273,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.6292597075242726,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.45433822014998243,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.7905160072650256
}
},
"Zoroastrianism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.1984187838844646,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.13470821213420756,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.009072493028053455,
"Fairness/Justice": -0.23848167643339985,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.10978460808195716,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": -0.27794713748760563,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.5177663459189413
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 1.0,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.9110417556871844,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.7356182319669399,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.3899615586296879,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.8762412508804286,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.33485644765783745,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.0
}
},
"Confucianism": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": -0.13894852073466804,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.18424285043787567,
"Embodied Discipline": -0.06961120071886466,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.05940898957788153,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.1298399486474517,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.02045841892513984,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": -0.16450372872873587
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.0732773008272548,
"Purity/Sanctity": 1.0,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.2720959392250752,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.6420499344873701,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.09939532644053196,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.5303626148702986,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.0
}
},
"Christianity": {
"raw_means": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.17373625173130736,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.2084933091503361,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.012200000019408686,
"Fairness/Justice": 0.7574194929771705,
"Truth/Integrity": -0.5140520178118809,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.28694796117495147,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.27421228231188766
},
"normalized": {
"Self-Mastery/Wisdom": 0.5409387970607062,
"Purity/Sanctity": 0.568274885304995,
"Embodied Discipline": 0.41389210325657033,
"Fairness/Justice": 1.0,
"Truth/Integrity": 0.0,
"Non-Violence/Stewardship": 0.6299787074975409,
"Prohibition/Embodied Practice": 0.6199622197076099
}
}
},
"nmf_results": {
"factor_variable_weights": {
"NMF_Factor_1": {
"self_restraint": 0.0,
"social_obligation": 9.6746592752929,
"ritual_observance": 0.0,
"epistemological": 0.0,
"physical_action": 0.8617065703300556,
"community_directed": 0.0,
"prohibition": 0.3814845212764139,
"internal_state": 1.032802200283186,
"divine_relationship": 0.0,
"justice_fairness": 0.30834881018367305,
"compassion_care": 10.519675804015709,
"purity_sanctity": 0.0,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.388638804452716,
"loyalty_covenant": 0.0,
"self_cultivation": 0.0,
"non_violence": 10.523864971139849,
"material_ethics": 0.0,
"speech_ethics": 0.0,
"sexual_ethics": 0.0,
"environmental": 3.965456545849737
},
"NMF_Factor_2": {
"self_restraint": 0.0,
"social_obligation": 1.9861821145097824,
"ritual_observance": 0.0,
"epistemological": 0.0,
"physical_action": 0.3578164765341637,
"community_directed": 2.377676021864653,
"prohibition": 0.0,
"internal_state": 0.7116780359217362,
"divine_relationship": 0.0,
"justice_fairness": 0.0,
"compassion_care": 2.3256561550714,
"purity_sanctity": 0.0,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.23989347512961967,
"loyalty_covenant": 2.2613970337016758,
"self_cultivation": 0.0,
"non_violence": 0.0,
"material_ethics": 0.23323122579214328,
"speech_ethics": 0.0,
"sexual_ethics": 0.012345537327093009,
"environmental": 0.0
},
"NMF_Factor_3": {
"self_restraint": 0.7005299773104813,
"social_obligation": 0.0,
"ritual_observance": 1.3274032770777615,
"epistemological": 0.0,
"physical_action": 3.2771969692204332,
"community_directed": 0.7457983906759896,
"prohibition": 0.0,
"internal_state": 0.0,
"divine_relationship": 0.1571363610777752,
"justice_fairness": 0.0,
"compassion_care": 0.0,
"purity_sanctity": 1.1634900151868934,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.0,
"loyalty_covenant": 0.0,
"self_cultivation": 0.4990927612363357,
"non_violence": 0.0,
"material_ethics": 0.12510266535773729,
"speech_ethics": 0.0,
"sexual_ethics": 0.0,
"environmental": 0.3272219866372528
},
"NMF_Factor_4": {
"self_restraint": 2.5886690065316373,
"social_obligation": 0.0,
"ritual_observance": 0.0,
"epistemological": 0.0,
"physical_action": 0.0,
"community_directed": 0.0,
"prohibition": 2.693753355448013,
"internal_state": 0.0,
"divine_relationship": 0.0,
"justice_fairness": 0.0,
"compassion_care": 0.0,
"purity_sanctity": 1.3601547661085116,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.0,
"loyalty_covenant": 0.07858824630852006,
"self_cultivation": 0.4292437785825023,
"non_violence": 0.0,
"material_ethics": 0.03772454956011452,
"speech_ethics": 0.10212767705534898,
"sexual_ethics": 0.6973095685671599,
"environmental": 0.0
},
"NMF_Factor_5": {
"self_restraint": 0.0,
"social_obligation": 0.0,
"ritual_observance": 0.9841241979648928,
"epistemological": 0.0,
"physical_action": 0.0,
"community_directed": 0.0,
"prohibition": 0.03354345037454756,
"internal_state": 0.750366750705909,
"divine_relationship": 2.377662356716769,
"justice_fairness": 0.0,
"compassion_care": 0.0,
"purity_sanctity": 0.0,
"authority_hierarchy": 2.2348120586060456,
"loyalty_covenant": 1.7157963040851192,
"self_cultivation": 0.0,
"non_violence": 0.0,
"material_ethics": 0.0,
"speech_ethics": 0.2726705362352845,
"sexual_ethics": 0.0,
"environmental": 0.0
},
"NMF_Factor_6": {
"self_restraint": 0.2373392496301252,
"social_obligation": 1.5774852691390069,
"ritual_observance": 0.0,
"epistemological": 0.07060105088690541,
"physical_action": 0.3289763238199029,
"community_directed": 0.0,
"prohibition": 0.0,
"internal_state": 0.0,
"divine_relationship": 0.0,
"justice_fairness": 2.1090728861853165,
"compassion_care": 0.03299452377102213,
"purity_sanctity": 0.0,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.0,
"loyalty_covenant": 0.0,
"self_cultivation": 0.0,
"non_violence": 0.0,
"material_ethics": 0.8286239539999032,
"speech_ethics": 0.6302761256706602,
"sexual_ethics": 0.0,
"environmental": 0.0
},
"NMF_Factor_7": {
"self_restraint": 0.6623612185206291,
"social_obligation": 0.0,
"ritual_observance": 0.0,
"epistemological": 1.399828846464917,
"physical_action": 0.0,
"community_directed": 0.0,
"prohibition": 0.0,
"internal_state": 1.9044912616077052,
"divine_relationship": 0.159069332441103,
"justice_fairness": 0.0,
"compassion_care": 0.0,
"purity_sanctity": 0.0,
"authority_hierarchy": 0.0,
"loyalty_covenant": 0.0,
"self_cultivation": 1.7728760939093549,
"non_violence": 0.027022215061471528,
"material_ethics": 0.0,
"speech_ethics": 0.0,
"sexual_ethics": 0.0,
"environmental": 0.0
}
},
"reconstruction_error": 9.621987674907205
},
"haidt_mapping": {
"Care/Harm": {
"description": "Evolved from mammalian attachment systems. Sensitivity to suffering.",
"key_emotions": "Compassion, empathy",
"related_variables": [
"compassion_care",
"non_violence"
],
"mapped_factor": "Non-Violence/Stewardship",
"mapping_strength": 0.89885034240556
},
"Fairness/Cheating": {
"description": "Evolved from reciprocal altruism. Sensitivity to proportionality and reciprocity.",
"key_emotions": "Gratitude, guilt, anger at cheaters",
"related_variables": [
"justice_fairness",
"material_ethics",
"speech_ethics"
],
"mapped_factor": "Fairness/Justice",
"mapping_strength": 1.2805192833251702
},
"Loyalty/Betrayal": {
"description": "Evolved from tribal coalitional psychology. In-group solidarity.",
"key_emotions": "Pride, rage at traitors",
"related_variables": [
"loyalty_covenant",
"community_directed"
],
"mapped_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom",
"mapping_strength": 0.6628990412800759
},
"Authority/Subversion": {
"description": "Evolved from primate social hierarchies. Respect for legitimate authority.",
"key_emotions": "Respect, fear",
"related_variables": [
"authority_hierarchy"
],
"mapped_factor": "Purity/Sanctity",
"mapping_strength": 0.5913699145494932
},
"Sanctity/Degradation": {
"description": "Evolved from pathogen-avoidance systems. Purity and contamination.",
"key_emotions": "Disgust, elevation",
"related_variables": [
"purity_sanctity",
"sexual_ethics",
"ritual_observance"
],
"mapped_factor": "Embodied Discipline",
"mapping_strength": 1.5837099380140374
},
"Liberty/Oppression": {
"description": "Sensitivity to domination and tyranny. Desire for autonomy.",
"key_emotions": "Reactance, resentment of bullies",
"related_variables": [
"self_cultivation",
"epistemological"
],
"mapped_factor": "Self-Mastery/Wisdom",
"mapping_strength": 1.5407658991964728
}
}
}